| Printable Version of Topic
Click here to view this topic in its original format |
| WorldWar2.ro Forum > Reviews & Bookstore > Three 2004/5 French books on ARR. Any good? |
| Posted by: sid guttridge May 28, 2005 07:02 am |
| Hi Guys, In a recent copy of the French publication "Air Magazine" I found the following three books advertised: "Les Bf109 Roumains" (AirMag Hors Serie No.1.) (15 Euros) "L'Aviation Roumaine pendant la Deuxieme Guerre Mondiale" by Medin Robinescu and Tudor Liviu Morosanu. (34 Euros) "IAR 80" (44 Euros). All appear to be issued by the publishers of AirMagazine, who seem to use the excellent art work of Morosanu a lot. Has anyone seen these books? How good are they? Are they worth the price? Many thanks, Sid. |
| Posted by: Victor May 28, 2005 07:34 am | ||||||
The author of the text is Vasile Tudor. It is a very good work, especially for those who do not have other books by the same author, which cover the Bf-109s in the 1942-45 period. He also planned a book on teh Bf-109E in the ARR, but unfortunately it hasn't been published yet. It is full of good information, but the author's writing style can be a little unusual for those who aren't used to it. A good aquisition. I think I paid only 10 Euros for it 2 years ago.
I have the Romanian version. Except for the color profiles, it doesn't bring anything new, at least to me, and I believe it was inspired too much by Denes Bernad's Squadron Signal book on ARR. I have it, but I don't usually use it.
The authors: Dan Antoniu and George Cicos are probably the only Romanians (together with Vasile Tudor and Valeriu Avram) that have spent a lot of years studying the archives and have tons of information, lacking unfortunately the funds to publish all they have. The book on the IAR-80, published in Romania in 2000, is a great book, although it contains many printing mistakes and gives teh information in a rather raw format, practically unfiltered, just as it was found in the archives, because of the rush to finally get it out of thge printing press. It is a superb book for those researching the IAR-80 in ARR service. If this is the French version, I think it is better written than the initial Romanian version and it contains more information. Hope this helps. |
| Posted by: D13-th_Mytzu May 28, 2005 08:10 am |
| Is the french version finally out or is it a pre-order thing ? |
| Posted by: sid guttridge May 28, 2005 08:13 am |
| Hi Victor, Many thanks. You have just cost me 59 Euros plus postage and packing for the Bf109 and IAR 80 books! I already have Denes's book so I will leave the "Aviation Roumaine....." book for now. Cheers, Sid. |
| Posted by: Victor May 28, 2005 10:33 am |
| Well, enjoy your reading and get back to me on how you found them. |
| Posted by: sid guttridge May 29, 2005 07:51 am |
| Hi D13th-Mytzu, The advert for "IAR 80" comes from the December/January 2004/5 issue of AirMagazine. It has "Souscription" at the top of the advert. Is this the French version of "pre-order"? In any case, I have sent my money off and will let you know if and when it arrives. I have a good feeling about this book. According to Victor, the authors are highly knowledgeable and I can see for myself in AirMag that the quality of Tudor Liviu Morosanu's colour and line illustration is extremely high. I presume he will have made a supreme effort for this particular subject. Cheers, Sid. |
| Posted by: sid guttridge May 29, 2005 08:13 am |
| P.S. For anyone wanting to know about these books, contact the publisher at: TMA 75 rue Claude Decaen Paris 75012 France Tel: 01 43 47 35 16 Fax: 01 43 47 34 37 E mail: airmagazine@wanadoo.fr |
| Posted by: Ruy Aballe May 29, 2005 10:09 am | ||
Yes, it is. You can pre-order the book, but you'll have to wait... As far as I know, the book is not available yet. Cheers, Ruy |
| Posted by: sid guttridge May 29, 2005 11:17 am |
| Hi Ruy, Thanks for clarifying that. I will not hold my breath waiting. Does anyone know if the Romanian edition is still available? Cheers, Sid. |
| Posted by: D13-th_Mytzu May 30, 2005 06:01 am |
| Yes, the romanian version is still available, however I was hoping for the french version to be more rafined - romanian version was published in a rush so it has a brut form. |
| Posted by: sid guttridge May 30, 2005 07:25 am |
| Hi D13-th-Mytzu, Thanks for that information. Could you give details of the full title, publisher and ISBN No.? Cheers, Sid. |
| Posted by: D13-th_Mytzu May 30, 2005 02:05 pm |
| Sure thing: Authors: Dan Antoniu, George Cicos Title: "Vanatorul IAR-80 Istoria unui erou necunoscut" Publsiher: Editura Modelism I.S.B.N. : 973-8101-07-7 |
| Posted by: sid guttridge May 30, 2005 02:24 pm |
| Hi D-13th-Mytzu, Many thanks. Sid. |
| Posted by: D13-th_Mytzu May 30, 2005 03:53 pm |
| Glad to be of assistance. |
| Posted by: MaxFax May 30, 2005 07:30 pm | ||||
That's correct ! The book is NOT yet available !! The "pre-order" status is "status quo" for about 2 years ...  |
| Posted by: Ruy Aballe May 30, 2005 08:14 pm |
| Yes, sadly... a friend of mine got so bored about the wait that he keeps saying the book will never see the day! I am always afraid of these long delays - normally, when the expected publication finally appears, it is either a fantastic achievement or a downright deception... Fortunately, I have the original Romanian edition. |
| Posted by: D13-th_Mytzu November 04, 2005 09:20 am |
| "Les Bf109 Roumains" I can't find info on it if I google that name, is this book still available ? Is it possible to order it from Romania ? |
| Posted by: MaxFax January 04, 2006 06:41 pm | ||
Do not hope much, but ... make a try at aeromagazin@rdslink.ro Maybe you are lucky ?!  |